Agatha Christie: The Indian Hotel Murder That Inspired the Queen of Crime The British author Agatha Christie is renowned for her gripping murder mysteries and clever plot twists. From "Murder on the Orient Express" to "And Then There Were None," her works continue to captivate readers around the world. But did you know that one of her most famous novels may have been inspired by a real-life murder case in India? In the early 20th century, Agatha Christie visited India with her husband, Colonel Archibald Christie, who was stationed there as part of the British Indian Army. During their stay, a notorious murder case took place that caught the attention of the entire nation and even made global headlines. This case is believed to have influenced Christie's first book, "The Mysterious Affair at Styles," which introduced her iconic detective character, Hercule Poirot. The murder that sparked Christie's interest occurred at the renowned Pahar Ganj Hotel in Allahabad, Northern India. On the night of February 17, 1911, a British army officer named Reginald Arthur Edward Scruby was found dead in his hotel room. Scruby, known for his charming personality, had checked into the hotel just a few days prior. The circumstances surrounding Scruby's death were perplexing. His body was found lying on the bed, fully clothed, with no signs of struggle. The only visible injury was a small mark on his forehead. The room showed no signs of forced entry, and all the doors and windows were locked from the inside. The hotel staff had not heard anything unusual during the night, leading to speculation that the murderer was someone known to Scruby. The investigation into Scruby's murder quickly became a sensation, with newspapers reporting every detail of the case. The case baffled the local police, who were unable to find any concrete evidence or suspects. As the investigation came to a standstill, public interest waned, and the case remained unsolved. It was during this time that Agatha Christie was living in India, immersing herself in the culture and local happenings. The murder at the Pahar Ganj Hotel must have caught her attention, prompting her to follow the case closely. It is believed that her observations and experiences during this period laid the groundwork for her future career as the queen of crime. "The Mysterious Affair at Styles," published in 1920, brought Christie's famous detective, Hercule Poirot, into the literary world. The novel is set in an English country house and revolves around the murder of a wealthy heiress. Poirot, a retired Belgian detective, is called in to solve the case and uses his keen observation and deductive skills to unravel the mystery. The book was an instant success and introduced readers to Christie's signature style of tightly woven plots and surprising revelations. While Agatha Christie never explicitly acknowledged that the murder at the Pahar Ganj Hotel inspired her debut novel, the similarities between the real-life case and "The Mysterious Affair at Styles" are hard to ignore. Both involve the murder of a charming army officer in a locked room, without any apparent signs of struggle. These elements, along with Christie's innate ability to craft intriguing mysteries, suggest a strong connection between the two. Agatha Christie went on to write 66 detective novels and 14 short story collections, creating memorable characters like Miss Marple and Tommy and Tuppence. Her works have sold over two billion copies worldwide, making her one of the best-selling authors of all time. The influence of the Pahar Ganj Hotel murder on Christie's writing cannot be understated. The mysterious circumstances and unsolved nature of the case likely served as a constant source of inspiration for the author. Whether consciously or subconsciously, Agatha Christie drew upon her experiences in India to create the intricate puzzles and suspenseful narratives that have captivated readers for generations. In conclusion, Agatha Christie's visit to India during the early 20th century coincided with a high-profile murder case that may have influenced her debut novel, "The Mysterious Affair at Styles." The unsolved murder at the Pahar Ganj Hotel captured the public's attention and left a lasting impression on the young author. Through her keen observations and writing prowess, Christie went on to become the queen of crime fiction, leaving an indelible mark on the literary world.
top of page
bottom of page