It’s not just Trump — crime and punishment are inherently political Lady Justice should be blind. The U.S. legal system should not use its full weight and resources to target political enemies. But these ideals obscure a key fact about American justice: Crime and punishment are inherently political. The concept of justice relies on the ability to enforce laws and hold individuals accountable for their actions. In a democratic society like the United States, the criminal justice system is supposed to be impartial and fair. However, the reality is that politics play a significant role in shaping the outcomes of criminal cases. One need only look at the recent impeachment trial of former President Donald Trump to see how political considerations can impact the criminal justice system. Despite the overwhelming evidence of his involvement in inciting the Capitol insurrection, Trump was acquitted by the Senate, largely due to partisan loyalty. This is not an isolated incident. Throughout history, politicians have used their influence to manipulate the criminal justice system to their advantage. From pardoning political allies to prosecuting political adversaries, the line between justice and politics is often blurred. One example of this is the infamous Watergate scandal. President Richard Nixon attempted to cover up his involvement in the break-in at the Democratic National Committee headquarters, leading to his eventual resignation. However, Nixon's successor, President Gerald Ford, controversially issued a pardon for Nixon, shielding him from criminal prosecution. Ford's decision was widely criticized as a political move to protect his own administration from further scrutiny. Even outside of the political arena, the criminal justice system is influenced by politics. In recent years, there has been a growing movement to reform the criminal justice system in the United States, particularly in relation to mass incarceration and racial disparities. Advocates argue that the enforcement of certain laws disproportionately targets minority communities and perpetuates systemic inequality. The war on drugs is a prime example of how politics have shaped the criminal justice system. Since its inception in the 1970s, the war on drugs has led to the mass incarceration of individuals, particularly people of color, for nonviolent drug offenses. Despite studies showing that drug use rates are similar across racial groups, African Americans and Hispanics are disproportionately arrested and sentenced for drug-related crimes. This disparity is not coincidental. The war on drugs served as a tool for politicians to appear tough on crime and win over conservative voters. By targeting low-level drug offenders, politicians could claim they were cracking down on crime, even though the policies had little impact on actual drug use. The political nature of crime and punishment is further highlighted by the existence of private prisons in the United States. These for-profit institutions rely on government contracts to house inmates, creating a financial incentive to keep incarceration rates high. Private prison companies often lobby for harsher sentencing laws and stricter immigration policies to ensure a steady stream of inmates and maximize their profits. The intersection of politics and the criminal justice system is not limited to the United States. In many countries, politicians use the legal system as a weapon to silence dissent and maintain their hold on power. Journalists, activists, and political opponents are frequently targeted with trumped-up charges, leading to their imprisonment or exile. While the ideal of a politically impartial criminal justice system may seem unattainable, there are steps that can be taken to mitigate the influence of politics on justice. One effective approach is to strengthen and protect the independence of the judiciary. By insulating judges from political pressure and ensuring their appointments are based on merit, rather than political allegiance, the integrity of the justice system can be preserved. Increased transparency and accountability are also essential in combating political interference in the criminal justice system. Public scrutiny and oversight can help hold politicians and law enforcement officials accountable for their actions, reducing the likelihood of abuses of power. Furthermore, there should be a concerted effort to address the underlying societal issues that contribute to crime. By investing in education, job training, and social services, policymakers can reduce the prevalence of crime and create a more equitable society. This approach would help to break the cycle of poverty and criminality, leading to safer communities and a less politicized criminal justice system. While it is unrealistic to expect a completely apolitical criminal justice system, there is an urgent need to address the influence of politics on the enforcement of laws and the administration of justice. By acknowledging the inherent political nature of crime and punishment, we can work towards a more equitable and just society. Lady Justice may not be blind, but with ongoing efforts, we can ensure that she is not swayed by the whims of politics either.
top of page
bottom of page