Law of Unintended Consequences Caused the Great Bond Rout Nobody could have predicted the Treasury market’s collapse of the last two years — apart from every critic of artificially low interest rates since John Locke. The bond market has been experiencing a turbulent time recently, with interest rates on the rise and bond prices falling. This phenomenon, known as the "Great Bond Rout," has left many investors and analysts scratching their heads. However, upon closer examination, it becomes clear that the root cause of this bond market turmoil is the law of unintended consequences. The concept of unintended consequences refers to the unforeseen effects of an action or policy. In the case of the Great Bond Rout, the unintended consequence is the result of years of artificially low interest rates set by central banks around the world. These low rates were implemented as a response to the 2008 financial crisis, with the aim of stimulating economic growth and encouraging borrowing and investment. Initially, these low interest rates had the desired effect. Borrowing became cheaper, and investors sought higher yields in the bond market. This led to a surge in demand for bonds, driving up their prices and pushing down yields. However, as with any policy, there are always unintended consequences. One unintended consequence of the low interest rate environment was the mispricing of risk. Investors were willing to accept lower yields in exchange for perceived safety, leading to a compression of credit spreads. This made riskier assets, such as corporate bonds, more attractive to investors, who were chasing higher returns in a low yield world. Another unintended consequence was the creation of a moral hazard. As interest rates remained artificially low for an extended period, investors became complacent and took on excessive risk. This is best exemplified by the rise of highly leveraged products, such as exchange-traded funds (ETFs). These funds offer exposure to a wide range of bond assets but do not have the same level of oversight as traditional mutual funds. As a result, investors who flocked to these products found themselves exposed to the risks associated with a sudden increase in interest rates. Furthermore, the low interest rate environment encouraged excessive debt accumulation. Governments, corporations, and individuals alike took advantage of cheap borrowing costs to fund their activities. This led to an increase in overall debt levels, making the economy more vulnerable to a sudden rise in interest rates. As the global economy began to recover and central banks signaled their intent to start raising interest rates, the bond market started to react. The increased supply of bonds coupled with the reduced demand caused by rising interest rates led to a decline in bond prices. This resulted in higher yields, as bond prices and yields move inversely. The unexpected consequences of the low interest rate environment have not been limited to the bond market. The stock market, too, has felt the impact. As interest rates rise, the cost of borrowing increases, making it more expensive for companies to finance growth and expansion. This can lead to a slowdown in corporate earnings and dampen investor sentiment. Additionally, higher interest rates make fixed income investments, such as bonds, more attractive relative to stocks, which can shift investor allocations away from equities. The Great Bond Rout serves as a reminder that actions taken to address one problem can inadvertently create new ones. While low interest rates may have helped stabilize the global economy in the aftermath of the financial crisis, the unintended consequences of this policy are now becoming apparent. The mispricing of risk, the creation of moral hazard, and the buildup of debt have all contributed to the bond market turmoil we are witnessing today. Moving forward, policymakers and investors must be mindful of the potential unintended consequences of their actions. It is essential to strike a balance between stimulating economic growth and ensuring long-term stability. This may involve implementing policies that promote sustainable borrowing and investment practices, as well as establishing mechanisms to monitor and control excessive risk-taking. In conclusion, the Great Bond Rout can be attributed to the law of unintended consequences brought about by years of artificially low interest rates. As interest rates rise, bond prices fall, leading to higher yields and market turmoil. The mispricing of risk, the creation of moral hazard, and the buildup of debt are all unintended consequences of the low interest rate environment. Going forward, it is crucial to consider the potential unintended consequences of policy decisions and take proactive measures to mitigate risks.
top of page
bottom of page